Chesapeake Shores vs Cedar Cove

I am a Hallmark Channel fan. That’s right; I admit it. They got me with their Christmas spectacular, and I just kept coming back for all their branded movie months.  It is a channel that has sweet, entirely predictable, fun movies and now television shows.

Since its expansion into branded content, the channel has started creating television shows.  Hallmark found success with their first venture, Cedar Cove, and kept going. Most recently they released a new series based on a series by author Sheryl Woods called Chesapeake Shores.

Now, let me say this now, I was a fan of Cedar Cove. One could argue that Cedar Cove died so Chesapeake Shores could live. Yeah, you could put it that way considering the ratings and age groups skew the same way.

However, three differences make Chesapeake Shores better than Cedar Cove. I write this a fan of both. While I miss Cedar Cove, Chesapeake Shores was a great replacement.

Family Core

Chesapeake Shores follows the O’Brien family. That includes a family of three girls and two boys. A mother, father, and Gran (the one that keeps the family together).  The family is the core or heart of the show. If they were to burst apart, the show would lose its sparkle. On Cedar Cove, you had Andie McDowall’s character as the lead but no family to bond over. There was no center of the show. Things just happened, and then people reacted.

Story Possibilities

Chesapeake Shores has a lot of possible narratives to follow. With that big of a family, each kid can have multiple storylines that can diverge off and then come back to involve different family members. I can see stories developing naturally for these characters. On Cedar Cove, the stories started out natural but then, in the second season at least, things began to appear forced. With a lot of characters from the books missing, a lot of the story shifted to characters that couldn’t handle it (cough the daughter cough).

Gran. Just Gran.

 Finally, one character rules above them all. The one person that ties the show together is Gran. The matriarch of the O’Brien family.  She is the only one who could go into a church, yell at God to bring back her grandson from war, and have it happen. She also has a secret history in her home country of Ireland that we are just starting to figure out.  On Cedar Cove, there is no such character. I guess the character of Grace was a lot of fun and had meaningful moments, but she isn’t like Gran. Sometimes a show needs that one character to love unconditionally.

Both shows are great, but I can see how Chesapeake Shores may have learned from Cedar Cove’s mistakes.  Try to stay close as possible to the books, create a home base, and have that one character you just can’t ignore. Some might find this show cliché or quaint, but I find it sweet. With television getting darker in tone every year it is nice to have a show be lighter and a little brighter. I guess I’m not the only one. According to Futon Critic, Chesapeake Shores is one of the most watched shows in network history among the 25-54 age group.

You can watch Chesapeake Shores on Sundays at 9 pm and Cedar Cove on Netflix.

For this Saturdays ‘Love it or Leave it’ I will be covering ABC’s Cristela.

Until then, have a great pop cultured day.


Add yours →

  1. I thought I would regret reading this but I’m glad I did. What a wonderful post! I’m a fan of what I’ve seen in Cedar Cove. It has that light-hearted feel to it. I’ve not seen Chesapeake Shores yet but I saw the first season has been added to Netflix. I’m really excited to watch it now. It’ll be an excellent choice for when I’m done watching Luke Cage this weekend.

  2. Add the chemistry between Abby and Trace that helps make Chesapeake shores win……the acting and story lines are so much better, too.

    • Hey! Cedar Cove did get too far from the books and Chesapeake Shores is staying relatively close from what I heard which might be why Chesapeake is doing a lot better than Cedar Cove did. Thanks for reading! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: